← Back to Home
SYSTEMATIC THEOLOGY
Before the Foundation of the World
God's Eternal Decrees
Nothing catches God off guard. Before a single atom was formed, the Triune God decreed all that would come to pass—including your salvation. The Divine Decrees are not a distant theological abstraction; they are the foundation of your assurance, the source of God's sovereignty, and the answer to the deepest questions about freedom, evil, and grace.
The Text
The doctrine of the Divine Decrees does not rest on isolated proof texts or creative eisegesis. It emerges from the clearest statements in Scripture about God's absolute control over the course of history and the destiny of nations and souls. These passages form a coherent testimony that God has decreed all things from eternity.
Ephesians 1:11 — The Comprehensive Decree
"In him we have obtained an inheritance, having been predestined according to the purpose of him who works all things according to the counsel of his will."
— Ephesians 1:11 (ESV)
Paul does not say God works some things or most things according to His will. He says God "works all things" (panta) according to the counsel of His will. This is comprehensive. Universal. All-encompassing. No exception clause. No reservation for human freedom to operate outside God's decree. God's sovereignty is not limited to the spiritual realm or the salvation of the elect; it extends to the totality of history.
Isaiah 46:9-10 — The Eternality of the Decree
"I am God, and there is no other; I am God, and there is none like me, declaring the end from the beginning and from ancient times things not yet done, saying, 'My counsel shall stand, and I will accomplish all my purpose.'"
— Isaiah 46:9-10 (ESV)
Isaiah does not describe God looking into the future and seeing what will happen. He describes God declaring the end from the beginning. God speaks the future into certainty because He has decreed it. "My counsel shall stand"—the word translated "counsel" (etzah in Hebrew) refers to God's deliberate plan, His fixed purpose. Nothing thwarts it; all it accomplishes God intends.
Acts 2:23 — The Crucifixion Was Decreed
"This Jesus, delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God, you crucified and killed by the hands of lawless men."
— Acts 2:23 (ESV)
Peter preaches on Pentecost and makes a stunning claim: the most evil act in human history—the crucifixion of the Son of God—was carried out "according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God." Here is the decree applied to history's darkest moment. God had decreed it. Yet the crucifixion was a genuine crime, performed by wickedness-filled men. The decree does not make God the author of their evil; it makes God sovereign over their evil.
Acts 4:27-28 — The Decree and Secondary Causes
"For truly in this city there were gathered together against your holy servant Jesus, whom you anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel, to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place."
— Acts 4:27-28 (ESV)
The early church prays and acknowledges that Herod, Pilate, Gentiles, and Jews all assembled to do "whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place." Enemies of Christ acted out of their own wickedness and will, yet their actions fulfilled God's predestined plan. The decree and human agency are not in conflict; they converge.
What Are the Divine Decrees?
The Divine Decrees are God's eternal, holy, wise, and free purpose, whereby He has foreordained whatsoever comes to pass. This is the traditional definition, drawn from the Westminster Shorter Catechism (Q7), and it captures the essential elements.
Understanding the Definition
To say God has decreed "whatsoever comes to pass" is not to say God decreed it to be evil. Rather, God decreed that it would come to pass—that the event would occur. The event itself might be good or evil, but the decree is God's determination that it will occur. A decree is not a description; it is a determination. God does not passively observe the future; God actively decrees it.
Crucial distinction: The decree is not the same as the execution. God's decree is eternal and unchanging. God's execution of the decree occurs in time. When did God decree that you would believe the gospel? Eternity. When did you believe the gospel? At a specific moment in time. The decree is timeless; the fulfillment is temporal. Both are real. Both are true. One does not annihilate the other.
Another critical point: There is one decree with many parts, not many decrees. God's decree is a single, unified purpose comprising all events. It is not that God decreed election in isolation, then separately decreed reprobation, then separately decreed the fall of man, then separately decreed the redemption of Christ. Rather, God decreed all of these as parts of one comprehensive, coherent plan. The decree is a unity; its manifestations are multiple.
Finally: The decree is all-comprehensive. Not just salvation, but all events. Not just the acts of the redeemed, but the acts of the reprobate. Not just the fall of man, but the fall of a sparrow. Not just the preaching of the gospel, but the weather that day. God "works all things according to the counsel of his will" (Ephesians 1:11). This is the scope of the decree. Nothing escapes it.
Attributes of the Divine Decrees
Reformed theology has identified seven essential characteristics of God's decrees. These attributes distinguish the doctrine of the Divine Decrees from lesser views of providence and from views that make God's sovereignty contingent on human choice.
Eternal
God's decrees are not new decisions that God makes in time. God does not sit in heaven and suddenly decide what will happen tomorrow. God's decrees are eternal—they existed in God's mind before time itself was created. God exists outside time; His decrees are therefore not subject to temporal succession. What God decrees today was always decreed.
Acts 15:18; Ephesians 1:4; 2 Timothy 1:9
Immutable
God's decrees cannot be changed or altered. They are fixed, permanent, and inviolable. No event occurs that was not decreed; no event fails to occur that was decreed. God's purposes cannot be thwarted or redirected. Once God has decreed a thing, it stands forever. What God has set in motion will come to its appointed end.
Hebrews 6:17; Isaiah 46:10; Psalm 33:11
Unconditional
God's decrees are not contingent on human actions, human choices, or human merit. God does not decree election "if you believe" or decree salvation "on the condition that you repent." Rather, God's decree is absolute and unconditional. God's knowledge of what you will freely choose does not condition God's decree; rather, God's decree ensures what you will freely choose.
Romans 9:11; Ephesians 1:5,11
All-Comprehensive
God's decrees extend to all events, great and small, good and evil. Not one sparrow falls outside the decree. Not one thought crosses your mind that God has not decreed. Not one atom moves contrary to the decree. From the largest movements of galaxies to the smallest details of your life, all fall within God's comprehensive purpose.
Ephesians 1:11; Proverbs 16:33; Matthew 10:29-30
Efficacious
God's decrees are not wishes or hopes that might fail. They are efficacious—they accomplish what God intends. When God decrees a thing, that thing will certainly come to pass. God's will is not merely directive (telling creatures what they should do); it is also efficacious (ensuring that what God intends is actually accomplished). God does not hope things work out; God ensures they do.
Isaiah 55:11; Daniel 4:35
Wise
God's decrees are not arbitrary, capricious, or foolish. They proceed from God's infinite wisdom. God knows all things—past, present, and future—exhaustively and immediately. God's decrees are therefore made with perfect knowledge and perfect understanding. What appears to us as mystery or contradiction is the result of our limited understanding, not of any flaw in God's wisdom.
Romans 11:33-36
Free
God's decrees are made freely, according to the good pleasure of God's will. God is under no obligation to decree anything. God does not decree in response to external compulsion or internal necessity. God decrees according to His own counsel, His own preference, His own sovereign delight. God's freedom is not diminished by the fact that God's decrees are eternal and immutable; rather, God's decrees are eternal because God eternally chose them.
Ephesians 1:5,9,11
The Decree and Predestination
The Divine Decrees are general; predestination is particular. The decrees encompass all things; predestination concerns the salvation of the elect and the damnation of the reprobate. Predestination is the application of the decree to persons—the eternal determination of who will be saved and who will be lost.
Election to Salvation
Election is God's eternal choice of certain persons to salvation. It is not based on foreseen faith or foreseen works. Rather, God chose those whom He purposed to save before the foundation of the world, in order that they might be holy and blameless before Him. This election is by grace alone, flowing from God's love and manifesting in the calling, justification, and ultimately the glorification of the elect.
"He chose us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and blameless before him. In love he predestined us for adoption to himself as sons through Jesus Christ, according to the purpose of his will."
— Ephesians 1:4-5 (ESV)
Reprobation — The Hard Doctrine
If God elects some to salvation, what of those not elect? Reformed theology addresses this with the doctrine of reprobation. Reprobation is God's eternal determination to leave certain persons in their sin and to ordain them to damnation as the just consequence of their sin. This is deeply uncomfortable; it should be. But Scripture states it plainly.
"So then he has mercy on whomever he wills, and he hardens whomever he wills. You will say to me then, 'Why does he still find fault? For who can resist his will?' But who are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to its molder, 'Why have you made me like this?' Has the potter no right over the clay, to make out of the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for dishonorable use?"
— Romans 9:18-21 (ESV)
Note: Paul anticipates the objection immediately: "Why does he still find fault? For who can resist his will?" The very question that troubles us is raised by Paul himself. And his answer is not to soften the doctrine but to appeal to God's sovereignty. God is the potter; we are the clay. The potter has absolute right over the clay. To object to God's reprobation is to shake your fist at your Creator.
Supralapsarianism vs. Infralapsarianism
Both views agree that God has decreed both election and reprobation. They differ on the logical order of the divine decrees.
Supralapsarianism
Supralapsarianism holds that God decreed election and reprobation before decreeing the fall of man. In the eternal order of God's decrees, God first purposed to save some and damn others; then God decreed to permit the fall so that this election and reprobation might be manifest. The decree of the fall is subordinate to the decree of predestination. God's predestination is not a response to the fall; the fall is an instrument through which predestination is executed.
Infralapsarianism
Infralapsarianism holds that God decreed the fall before decreeing election and reprobation. In the eternal order of God's decrees, God first allowed the fall of man; then, in view of fallen humanity, God decreed to elect some to salvation and leave others in their sin (reprobation). The decree of predestination is a response to the decree of the fall. God's election and reprobation are God's determination concerning sinners, not concerning innocent persons.
Both views are held by Reformed theologians of unquestionable orthodoxy. Both views maintain the absolute sovereignty of God and the total depravity of man. The difference is subtle: the order of logical priority in God's eternal decrees. Neither view denies that God has decreed both election and reprobation; both agree that God's decrees are eternal and immutable. The most important point is not which view you hold, but that you hold firmly to the sovereignty of God and the reality of human responsibility.
The Decree to Permit Sin
One of the most vexing questions: How can God decree sin and yet not be the author of sin? The answer lies in understanding the distinction between ordaining that sin will occur and causing someone to sin.
God decreed that sin would come to pass. The fall of Adam was not a surprise to God. God ordained that sin would occur in the world. Yet God is not the author of sin. Why? Because God ordains sin by permitting it, not by causing it. When you commit a sin, you do so willingly, freely, genuinely. You are the author of your sin. God did not cause you to sin; God decreed that you would freely sin. The decree and your free agency are not in conflict.
"As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive, as they are today."
— Genesis 50:20 (ESV)
Joseph's brothers meant evil. They genuinely intended to harm Joseph. Yet God's purpose was good—He was working through their evil intention to accomplish His redemptive design. Here is the pattern: human agents act according to their own will and intention, yet God's decree is accomplished through their willing action. The decree does not override human agency; it works through human agency.
The Decree and Providence
It is crucial to distinguish between God's decree and God's providence. The decree is God's eternal purpose; providence is God's execution of that purpose in time. The decree is made once and never changes; providence is the continuous working out of that decree through history.
The Decree = God's eternal plan, made before the foundation of the world.
Providence = God's continuous working out of that plan through time.
God Governs All Creatures and Actions
God's providence extends to all creatures and all their actions. Not one event in the universe occurs outside God's governance. Kings are not exempt; weather patterns are not exempt; your thoughts and choices are not exempt.
"The king's heart is a stream of water in the hand of the Lord; he turns it wherever he will."
— Proverbs 21:1 (ESV)
This is not flowery language or poetry meant to be softened. The king's heart—the will and inclination of the most powerful human being—is in God's hand as water flows in whatever direction the one holding it directs. God's providence over human will is absolute.
Primary and Secondary Causes
God is the primary cause of all things. But God does not act in isolation. God works through secondary causes—the natural laws, the human will, the actions of creatures. When you choose to believe the gospel, your choice is a secondary cause. But your choice does not frustrate God's purpose; rather, God's providence works through your choice to accomplish His purpose.
The rain falls because of the laws of evaporation and meteorology (secondary causes). Yet God sends the rain (primary cause). Both are true. The laws of nature and God's sovereignty are not in competition; God works through the laws of nature to accomplish His purposes.
Concurrence — God and Human Agency
The doctrine of concurrence explains how God's activity and human activity exist in the same event without contradiction. God is actively involved in all your actions, yet you are genuinely free. You act according to your own will, yet your will is under God's providential direction.
"For it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure."
— Philippians 2:12-13 (ESV)
This is concurrence: God is working in you to will, and you are willing. God is working in you to work, and you are working. The activity is simultaneous and unified. It is not that God works 99% and you work 1%. Rather, God works 100% and you work 100%, and these are not in competition. This is the mystery of divine sovereignty and human responsibility, and Scripture affirms both.
The Greek and Hebrew
The language of the original biblical texts makes clear the comprehensive nature of God's decrees and the certainty of their accomplishment. Several key words appear repeatedly.
βουλή (boulē)
"Counsel" / "Deliberate purpose"
From bouleuo (to deliberate, to purpose). This word emphasizes the deliberate intention behind a choice. When Scripture speaks of "the counsel of God's will" (boulēs tou thelematos autou), it means God's deliberate, intentional purpose. God does not accidentally decree; God deliberately, with full intention and knowledge, purposes all things.
πρόθεσις (prothesis)
"Purpose" / "Plan set forth"
From pro (before) and tithemi (to set, to place). Literally, "to place before" or "to set forth beforehand." In Romans 8:28 and Ephesians 1:11, prothesis refers to God's predetermined purpose. It is a plan established in advance, not a response to events as they unfold. God's purpose is set forth before creation; creation unfolds according to that purpose.
προορίζω (proorizō)
"To predetermine" / "To set boundaries beforehand"
From pro (before) and horizō (to set boundaries, to determine). This word appears in Acts 4:28 regarding the crucifixion and in Romans 8:29-30 regarding election. It means God has set the boundaries of what will occur beforehand. The limits are fixed; the course is determined. Nothing spills outside the boundaries God has set.
εὐδοκία (eudokia)
"Good pleasure" / "Sovereign delight"
From eu (good) and dokeo (to seem, to be pleased). God acts according to His eudokia—His good pleasure, His sovereign delight, His will to do something. In Ephesians 1:5 and 1:9, Paul emphasizes that God acts "according to the purpose of his will" (kata tēn eudokian tou thelematos autou). God's decrees flow from God's sovereign, benevolent will.
يَعَץ (ya'ats) [Hebrew]
"To counsel" / "To plan"
In Isaiah 46:10, God declares "My counsel shall stand, and I will accomplish all my purpose." The Hebrew etzah (counsel) refers to a deliberate plan, a fixed purpose. God's counsel is not conditional on human action; it is established and will be accomplished. When God councils, God acts; God's counsel and God's action are inseparable.
Critical Arguments for the Divine Decrees
The doctrine of the Divine Decrees rests not on isolated proof texts but on converging lines of argument from Scripture, reason, and the nature of God. These arguments demonstrate that God's sovereignty and God's decrees are necessary conclusions from Scripture itself.
Argument 1
The Crucifixion Was Decreed — Acts 2:23
The most evil act in human history—the murder of the Son of God—occurred "according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God." Here is a decree in action. The crucifixion was the wickedest deed ever committed, performed by wicked men with wicked intention. Yet it was decreed. God had ordained it. The greatest crime was the greatest fulfillment of God's purpose. If the crucifixion was decreed, then events are decreed. If events are decreed, then God's decree is not limited to salvation; it extends to the course of history itself.
Argument 2
Not One Sparrow Falls Outside God's Decree — Matthew 10:29-30
"Are not two sparrows sold for a penny? And not one of them will fall to the ground apart from your Father... But even the hairs of your head are all numbered." Jesus establishes that God's knowledge and care extend to the smallest details. Not one sparrow falls outside God's knowledge. If God knows every event before it occurs and has decreed the world such that events occur exactly as He knew they would, then the decree extends to sparrows and to hairs. God's decree is comprehensive. It is not just about nations and kings; it is about your next thought, your next breath.
Argument 3
The Decree Does Not Make God the Author of Sin — Genesis 50:20 & Acts 4:27-28
Joseph's brothers sinned in their hatred and betrayal. Yet God's purpose was accomplished through their sin. God ordained the event, but the brothers authored the sin. How? Because they acted according to their own will. God's decree is not coercive; it works through human agency. God decreed that the crucifixion would occur, yet those who crucified Jesus were guilty of murder. The decree and responsibility are not in conflict. God ordains events; humans author sins within those events. The distinction is crucial: God ordains the occurrence; humans are responsible for the wickedness.
Argument 4
The Decree Grounds Assurance — Romans 8:28-39
Paul writes: "We know that for those who love God all things work together for good, for those who are called according to his purpose." This assurance is grounded in God's decree. If God had not decreed that all things work together for the good of the elect, then there would be no assurance. Things might work together for evil. Circumstances might conspire against you. But God has decreed that for those who are called according to His purpose, all things—even the most terrible circumstances—work together for good. Your assurance does not rest on your strength or your faith; it rests on the immutable decree of God. Nothing can snatch you from God's hand because God has decreed your perseverance.
Argument 5
Without the Decree, God Is Not Sovereign — Ephesians 1:11
Paul declares that God "works all things according to the counsel of his will." If some things are outside God's decree—if some events happen contrary to God's will or without God's determination—then God is not truly sovereign. Sovereignty means ultimate power over all things. A God who does not decree all things is not the ultimate power; something or someone else is. But the God of Scripture is sovereign. Therefore, God must decree all things. The doctrine of the Divine Decrees is not an optional theological refinement; it is the logical necessity of God's absolute sovereignty.
Core Arguments Summary
- The crucifixion—the greatest evil—was decreed by God, proving events are decreed.
- Not one sparrow falls outside God's decree; therefore, the decree is comprehensive.
- God decreed sin certainly, yet humans author their own sins; decree and responsibility are compatible.
- Your assurance rests on God's immutable decree, not on circumstance or feelings.
- Without the decree of all things, God is not truly sovereign.
Objections & Answers
This is the most serious objection. If God decreed that I would sin, and I sin, then God is responsible for my sin. God is the author of evil. This makes God morally culpable and contradicts God's holiness.
This distinction is affirmed in the Westminster Confession of Faith 3.1: God "neither is nor can be the author or approver of sin." Yet God has "most wisely and powerfully...permitted all things to come to pass." God's decree is not coercive. It does not eliminate human agency; it works through human agency. When you sin, you sin because you desire to sin, you choose to sin, you act willingly and freely. You are the author of your sin. God has ordained that you would freely sin, but God did not cause the sinfulness of your choice. You did. Genesis 50:20 illustrates this: Joseph's brothers sinned wickedly, but God's purpose was accomplished. God decreed the event (Joseph's removal from the family); the brothers authored the evil (the betrayal and sale). The decree is about the occurrence; the moral culpability is on the agent. God's decree does not override human responsibility; it establishes the framework within which human responsibility is real.
If God has decreed all my choices, then I am not free. My choices are not really my own; they are determined by God's decree. I cannot be held responsible for choices I did not freely make. Free will and divine decree are incompatible.
Acts 2:23 demonstrates the compatibility: "This Jesus, delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God, you crucified and killed by the hands of lawless men." The crucifixion was decreed by God and freely chosen by wicked men. Both are asserted without any tension or apology. The men who crucified Jesus were guilty; they acted from their own wicked intention. Yet their actions occurred "according to the definite plan of God." The decree does not make your choices less free; it ensures that your choices are exactly what you freely will. Your freedom is not freedom from God's decree; your freedom is the freedom to act according to your own desire, your own nature, your own will—and God has decreed that you will freely act according to your nature. This is true freedom: acting according to your own desires without external coercion. When you choose to believe the gospel, you freely choose it. God has decreed that you would freely choose it. Both are true.
If God decreed that I would sin, then it is unfair to judge me for sinning. I did not have a real choice; God made me sin. Therefore, God cannot justly condemn me.
You are not compelled to sin; you sin according to your own nature. Romans 9:19-21 addresses this objection directly: "You will say to me then, 'Why does he still find fault? For who can resist his will?'" Paul's answer is: "Who are you, O man, to answer back to God?" Paul does not argue that God's decree is compatible with human freedom (though it is). Paul appeals to God's sovereignty. God is the potter; you are the clay. The potter has the right to make vessels for dishonorable use. This may seem unjust to us, but it is the prerogative of the sovereign. However, note: God does not decree that you would be unwilling to sin. God decreed that you would freely sin. Therefore, you are justly judged. You committed the sin willingly. You are responsible.
If God decrees that some persons are reprobate—destined for damnation—then God is arbitrary and unjust. Why would God decree that some would be damned? This seems to violate any sense of fairness.
Romans 9 addresses this directly. Paul writes: "What then shall we say? Is there injustice on God's part? By no means!" (Romans 9:14). Then he argues from God's right over creation: God is the potter; sinners are the clay. God has the right to ordain vessels for dishonorable use. This is not an answer we like, but it is Scripture's answer. Furthermore, reprobation is not positive damnation; it is the withholding of grace. No one deserves God's grace. All deserve damnation. If God leaves some in their sin (reprobation), this is not unjust; it is what all deserve. If God saves some (election), this is not unjust; it is pure mercy. The real question is not "Why does God reprobate?" but "Why does God elect at all?" If anyone receives what they deserve, it is the reprobate. If anyone receives mercy, it is the elect.
If God has decreed all things, then prayer cannot change anything. Prayer is futile. God will accomplish His purposes regardless of my prayers. So why pray?
This is a common misunderstanding. God has decreed not only what will happen but also the means through which it will happen. If God has decreed that you will be sanctified, God has also decreed that you will pray, read Scripture, and submit to the Holy Spirit as the means of your sanctification. Prayer is not a way to change God's mind; prayer is God's appointed means. When you pray for a lost friend's conversion, you are not trying to convince God to do something He has not decreed. Rather, you are the instrument God is using to accomplish the decree. Your prayer is part of God's decreed plan. Isaiah 65:24 says: "Before they call I will answer; while they are yet speaking I will hear." God has decreed to answer your prayer, and your prayer is the appointed means through which God accomplishes that answer. Prayer is not futile; it is essential. God works through prayer.
The Witnesses — The Great Theologians Affirm
The doctrine of the Divine Decrees is not a modern invention or the opinion of one theologian. It has been affirmed by the greatest Reformed theologians and confessions throughout history.
Westminster Confession of Faith
3.1-8 — The classic Reformed statement of the doctrine of predestination and God's decrees
Francis Turretin
Institutes of Elenctic Theology — Detailed defense of the decrees against all objections
John Owen
Works — Extensive treatment of God's sovereignty and the compatibility of divine decree with human responsibility
Jonathan Edwards
Freedom of the Will — The classic philosophical defense of compatibilism and divine sovereignty
R.C. Sproul
Chosen by God — Modern accessible treatment of election and the divine decrees
Herman Bavinck
Reformed Dogmatics — Comprehensive systematic theology affirming God's sovereign decrees
These witnesses span centuries and contexts, yet they are unified in affirming that God has decreed all things according to His wise and holy purpose. This is not sectarian doctrine; it is the teaching of the Great Tradition of Reformed theology.
Connections — Further Exploration
The doctrine of the Divine Decrees does not stand in isolation. It connects to other essential doctrines of Reformed theology. Understanding these connections deepens your grasp of how God's sovereignty permeates all His purposes.
The Golden Chain
Foreknowledge, predestination, calling, justification, glorification
Further Reading
- Westminster Confession of Faith, Chapter 3 — Of God's Eternal Decree — The foundational Reformed statement
- Francis Turretin, Institutes of Elenctic Theology, Locus 5 — On God's Decrees and Predestination — Detailed philosophical and biblical defense
- John Owen, "The Doctrine of the Saints' Perseverance Explained and Confirmed" — How God's decrees ensure the believer's security
- Jonathan Edwards, "Freedom of the Will" — The philosophical masterpiece on compatibilism
- R.C. Sproul, "Chosen by God" — Modern, accessible treatment of election flowing from the decrees
- Herman Bavinck, "Reformed Dogmatics" Vol. 2, Chapter 3 — Comprehensive treatment of God's providence and decrees
- Sinclair Ferguson, "The Whole Christ" — How God's decrees reveal Christ as the center of all things